क्यों है हमारा Electricity Bill इतना ज़्यादा?
Why Is Our Electricity Bill So High?
Capital Gateway Society, Sector 111, Gurugram — A complete analysis of what we pay, why it's unfair, and what similar neighbouring societies actually pay.
Plain language · सरल भाषा · Every resident can understand exactly what is happening with our electricity charges
Visit 1 — Wrong Office (Sector-23)
पहली बार गलत office गए — यहाँ Sector-110 के मामले नहीं देखे जाते
Went to DHBVN Office, Sector-23
This is the Sub-Divisional Officer's office. Found the address online.
सरकारी बिजली दफ्तर, Sector-23 गए — address internet पर मिला।
Told: Sector-110 Not Under This Office
The officials said our area (Sector-110/111) is handled by a different DHBVN office.
अधिकारियों ने कहा — Sector-110 का काम यहाँ नहीं होता।
Redirected to Pillar No. 62, Dwarka Expressway
The relevant DHBVN office is near Pillar No. 62, Sector-110. The Junior Engineer (JE) there handles our area.
Pillar No. 62, Sector-110 वाले DHBVN office जाने को कहा।
Visit 2 — Correct Office (Sector-110)
दूसरी बार सही office — यहाँ बड़ी जानकारी मिली
📍 G257+XMJ, New Palam Vihar, Block T, Sector 109, Gurugram — 122006
Raised Our Problem
Told the Junior Engineer (JE) that residents are paying very high electricity rates. Requested that each flat should get its own separate DHBVN meter connection.
JE को बताया — हम बहुत ज्यादा pay कर रहे हैं। हर flat को अलग connection चाहिए।
JE's First Answer: "Not Possible"
He said DHBVN gives only one single connection to an apartment building. Individual connections for each flat are not given.
JE बोले — apartment building को एक ही connection मिलता है, अलग-अलग नहीं।
DHBVN's Official Position
From DHBVN's side — they supply electricity to the building. What the builder or maintenance agency charges residents inside the building is not DHBVN's concern.
DHBVN का कहना — building को बिजली देना हमारा काम, अंदर क्या charge होता है — वो builder का मामला।
हमारे builder को DHBVN के Unified Portal पर register करके हर flat के लिए अलग connection apply करना होगा।
The Question We Asked the JE:
"If individual connections are not possible in a builder floor society, then how is it that Atharva Raheja — a private builder in Sector 109 — already has DHBVN individual connections for each flat?"
यदि यह possible नहीं है, तो Atharva Raheja में हर flat का अलग DHBVN connection कैसे है?
JE's Initial Stand (Wrong)
JE का पहला जवाब — जो बाद में गलत निकला
- Individual connections not possible in builder societies
- DHBVN gives only one connection to the building
- Internal billing is the builder's agreement — DHBVN cannot interfere
After Cross-Question — Real Answer
सवाल पूछने के बाद सच सामने आया
- JE was surprised — he did not know about this initially
- After checking with his assistant — confirmed: there IS a separate Builder Portal on DHBVN's system
- Through this portal, the builder can apply for individual connections for each flat
- This is the same system used by Atharva Raheja
Conclusion: DHBVN provides individual electricity connections in builder societies through the Unified Builder Portal. Our builder just needs to apply.
हमारा builder DHBVN के portal पर apply करे — हर flat को अलग meter मिल सकता है।
What Builder Can Do on DHBVN Portal
अभी ₹1,280 हर महीने बिना बिजली use किये भी देना पड़ता है। नए system में यह charge बंद हो जाएगा।
✅ No Meter Replacement Needed
कोई नया meter नहीं लगवाना
Existing meters will continue to work. No cost to residents for replacing equipment.
📊 New Rate Structure
नई billing system के rates
- DHBVN Energy: ₹6.60/unit
- Distribution charge: ₹0.40/unit
- Effective rate: ~₹7.00/unit
- GST: 18% on bill amount
❌ Fixed Grid Charge Removed
₹1,280 का fixed charge बंद होगा
The ₹1,280 fixed grid charge (₹160 × 8 kW) is eliminated. Its associated GST of ~₹230 is also removed.
✅ Pay Only What You Use
जितना use करो उतना pay करो
100 units = bill for 100 units. 300 units = bill for 300 units. No minimum charge, no hidden fixed cost.
How Much Would You Save Each Month?
| Monthly Usage | Current Bill (with ₹1,280 fixed charge) | New Bill (without fixed charge) | Monthly Saving |
|---|---|---|---|
| 100 Units | ₹700 + ₹1,280 = ₹1,980 | ₹700 + GST ₹126 = ₹826 | ₹1,280 saved |
| 200 Units | ₹1,400 + ₹1,280 = ₹2,680 | ₹1,400 + GST ₹252 = ₹1,652 | ₹1,280 saved |
| 300 Units | ₹2,100 + ₹1,280 = ₹3,380 | ₹2,100 + GST ₹378 = ₹2,478 | ₹1,280 saved |
Note: The ₹1,280 saving is the same regardless of how many units you consume — because it is a fixed charge that disappears entirely.
Atharva Raheja का bill proof है कि fair billing कैसी होती है — सिर्फ actual use का charge।
Their Actual Bill (Invoice No. 112235, May 2026)
May 2026 का actual bill — 907 Grid units + 19 DG units
| Charge Component | What It Is | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Grid Energy (907 units × ₹6.6) | Actual electricity used | ₹5,986 |
| DHBVN Fixed Charge (907 × ₹0.449) | Per-unit metering cost | ₹407 |
| FPPAS (907 × ₹0.47) | Govt. fuel adjustment | ₹426 |
| Electricity Duty (907 × ₹0.10) | State tax | ₹90.70 |
| Municipal Tax (907 × ₹0.1504) | Local body tax | ₹136 |
| DG Units (19 units × ₹29.36) | Generator usage charge | ₹558 |
| SGST + CGST @ 9% each (DG) | GST on DG only | ₹100 |
| Total Bill Amount | ₹7,705 | |
✅ No separate ₹1,280 fixed load charge. No DG maintenance fixed charge. No software fee.
Bill for 100 Units — Raheja Model
100 units के लिए कितना pay होगा — fair billing में
| Component | Rate | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Electricity (consumption) | ₹6.60/unit | ₹660 |
| Fixed Charge component | ₹0.449/unit | ₹44.90 |
| FPPAS (fuel levy) | ₹0.47/unit | ₹47 |
| Electricity Duty (tax) | ₹0.10/unit | ₹10 |
| Municipal Tax | ₹0.15/unit | ₹15 |
| Total for 100 units | ₹776.94 | |
What the ₹1,280 Fixed Charge Actually Costs You
₹1,280 fixed charge का असली असर — 100 units example
| Scenario (100 Units) | Amount |
|---|---|
| Fair bill (Raheja model) | ₹776.94 |
| With ₹1,280 fixed charge added | ₹2,056.94 |
| Extra you pay due to fixed charge | ₹1,280 every month |
This ₹1,280 extra is the same whether you use 100 units or 500 units. It never changes.
Capital Gateway में generator use हो या नहीं — ₹531 हर महीने देना पड़ता है।
✅ If generator doesn't run → you pay ₹0 for DG
| What We're Comparing | Atharva Raheja (Fair) | Capital Gateway (Us) |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed monthly DG charge | ₹0 — Not charged | ₹450/month |
| GST on fixed DG charge | ₹0 — Not applicable | ₹81/month |
| Total fixed DG burden | ₹0 every month | ₹531 every month |
| DG unit charges | Only for units consumed | Charged separately on top |
| If generator never ran | Pay ₹0 for DG | Still pay ₹531 |
| Billing model | Pay-as-you-use | Fixed monthly + per unit |
❓ Key Question for Society Management
If Atharva Raheja — a private builder — can run DG billing purely on actual consumption with zero fixed charges, why does Capital Gateway charge residents ₹531 every month regardless of whether the generator ran?
Sobha City, जो हमारे पड़ोस में है, वहाँ कोई fixed charge नहीं है। यह prove करता है कि हमारे fixed charges जरूरी नहीं हैं।
Sobha City — Tariff Rates
Sobha City के electricity rates
| Type | Rate |
|---|---|
| Grid (normal) electricity | ₹7.02/unit |
| DG (generator) electricity | ₹24.00/unit + GST |
| Shop Grid electricity | ₹8.10/unit |
Sobha City — All Fixed Charges = ₹0
सभी fixed charges शून्य — यही fair billing है
✅ Consumption-based billing only
✅ Transparent declared tariff
✅ No hidden fixed charges
✅ No software fee
| Charge Type | Sobha City (Sector 108) | Capital Gateway (Us) |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed Grid Charge | ₹0 — Not charged | ₹1,280/month (₹160 × 8 kW) |
| Fixed DG Charge | ₹0 — Not charged | ₹531/month (₹90 × 5 kW + GST) |
| MMC Charge | ₹0 — Not charged | Applicable |
| GST on Fixed Charges | Not Applicable | Applicable (adds ~₹230) |
| Grid consumption billing | Consumption-based only | Consumption + fixed charges |
❓ Key Question
If Sobha Limited — a professional developer managing a large premium society — can operate with Fixed Grid Charge = ₹0 and Fixed DG Charge = ₹0, then why is Capital Gateway charging residents these fixed amounts every month?
ATS Kukoon — वही type की society, पर maintenance ₹1.50/sq.ft. कम और DG rate ₹3.34/unit कम।
For a 1,900 sq.ft. flat: we pay ₹9,500/month in maintenance vs ATS Kukoon residents who would pay only ₹6,650/month — a difference of ₹2,850/month = ₹34,200/year extra maintenance alone.
1,900 sq.ft. flat पर हम ₹2,850 ज्यादा maintenance देते हैं ATS Kukoon से — हर महीने।
तीनों societies में same बिजली use करने पर Capital Gateway का bill सबसे ज्यादा है — ₹1,931 ज्यादा।
⚡ Grid Electricity Bill — 200 Units
| Charge | Capital Gateway | Raheja Atlantis | Sobha City |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base Rate per unit | ₹8.00/unit (higher) | ₹6.60/unit | ₹7.02/unit |
| DHBVN Fixed Charges | Bundled in ₹8 | ₹89.80 | — |
| FPPAS (fuel levy) | — | ₹94.00 | — |
| Electricity Duty (state tax) | — | ₹20.00 | — |
| Municipal Tax | — | ₹30.08 | — |
| GST | Nil | Nil | Nil |
| Grid Subtotal | ₹1,600 | ₹1,553.88 | ₹1,404 |
🔋 DG Generator Bill — 20 Units
| Charge | Capital Gateway | Raheja Atlantis | Sobha City |
|---|---|---|---|
| DG Rate per unit | ₹30/unit | ₹29.36/unit | ₹24/unit |
| DG Unit Charge (20 units) | ₹600 | ₹587.20 | ₹480 |
| Fixed DG Maintenance Charge | ₹450 (always charged) | ₹0 — None | Included in rate |
| Taxable Amount | ₹1,050 | ₹587.20 | ₹480 |
| GST @ 18% | ₹189 (IGST) | ₹105.70 | ₹86.40 |
| DG Subtotal (incl. GST) | ₹1,239 | ₹692.90 | ₹566.40 |
📋 Fixed Charges (Regardless of Usage)
| Fixed Charge | Capital Gateway | Raheja Atlantis | Sobha City |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grid Meter / Load Charge | ₹1,280 (always paid) | Not charged | Not charged |
| CAM / Common Area Maintenance | ₹0 (nil) | — | ₹542.10 |
| Software / Platform Fee | ₹59 (always paid) | — | — |
| Fixed Subtotal | ₹1,339 | ₹0 | ₹542.10 |
Basis: 200 grid units + 20 DG units consumed. Fixed charges as per published tariffs. May 2026 data.
हर साल ₹21,468 सिर्फ fixed charges में जाते हैं — चाहे हम बिजली use करें या नहीं।
Monthly Fixed Charges — What Each Society Pays
| Fixed Charge Item | Capital Gateway | Raheja Atlantis | Sobha City |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grid Meter/Load Charge | ₹1,280 (8kW × ₹160) | Not charged | Not charged |
| DG Maintenance Fixed | ₹450 (5kW × ₹90) | Not charged | Included in DG tariff |
| CAM / Common Area Fee | ₹0 (nil) | — | ₹542.10 |
| Software / System Fee | ₹59 (₹50 + ₹9 GST) | — | — |
| Monthly Fixed Total | ₹1,789 | ₹0 visible | ₹542.10 |
Yearly Impact (× 12 months)
| Annual Fixed Cost | Capital Gateway | Raheja Atlantis | Sobha City |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grid Load Charge (yearly) | ₹15,360 | ₹0 | ₹0 |
| DG Maintenance (yearly) | ₹5,400 | ₹0 | ₹0 |
| CAM (yearly) | ₹0 | — | ₹6,505 |
| Software Fee (yearly) | ₹708 | ₹0 | ₹0 |
| Total Fixed Paid Per Year | ₹21,468 | Not itemised | ₹6,505 |
How Much Could Each Flat Save Per Year?
| Saving Category | vs Raheja Atlantis | vs Sobha City |
|---|---|---|
| Grid Load Charge (stopped) | ₹15,360 saved | ₹15,360 saved |
| DG Maintenance (stopped) | ₹5,400 saved | ₹5,400 saved |
| Software Fee (stopped) | ₹708 saved | ₹708 saved |
| CAM (would be added) | Not applicable | −₹6,505 (new cost) |
| Net Annual Saving Per Flat | ≥ ₹21,468 / year | ₹14,963 / year |
₹9,500 हर महीने देते हैं — पर कहाँ जाता है? कोई हिसाब नहीं दिया गया कभी।
For all 10 services listed below, the society has NOT provided any expense breakup. Residents have no way to verify if the money is being spent correctly.
नीचे दी गई 10 सेवाओं में से किसी का भी expense society ने नहीं बताया।
1. Security
सुरक्षा guards पर खर्च
How many guards? What salary? Contract with which agency? — No details given.
2. Housekeeping
सफाई पर खर्च
How many cleaners? Daily/weekly schedule? Cost per month? — No details given.
3. Lift Maintenance
लिफ्ट maintenance पर खर्च
AMC contract? Company name? Annual cost? — No details given.
4. Common Area Electricity
Common areas की बिजली पर खर्च
Monthly unit consumption for corridors, parking, lobby? — No details given.
5. DG Maintenance
Generator maintenance पर खर्च
Is this already covered in the ₹531 DG fixed charge? Double charged? — No details given.
6. Water Supply
पानी की supply पर खर्च
Borewell? Tanker? Motor electricity? Monthly cost? — No details given.
7. STP / WTP Plant
Sewage Treatment Plant खर्च
The sewage and water treatment plant running costs? — No details given.
8. Landscaping
बगीचे और greenery पर खर्च
Garden maintenance, plant replacement, tools? — No details given.
9. Club House
Club house operations खर्च
Electricity, cleaning, maintenance of club facilities? — No details given.
10. Swimming Pool
Swimming pool maintenance खर्च
Chemicals, cleaning, pump electricity? — No details given.
Five Questions Residents Are Asking:
- How much is spent on each of the 10 services?
- Is DG cost already included in this ₹9,500? If yes, why are we also paying ₹531 separately in the electricity bill?
- Is electricity infrastructure cost included? If yes, why is there a ₹1,280 grid charge also?
- Why is there no detailed monthly expense statement shared with residents?
- Why is there no audited annual expense report?
यह पाँच सवाल society management को जवाब देने होंगे।
₹9,500 maintenance + electricity bill — दोनों में कुछ same charges तो नहीं हैं? अगर हैं, तो double charging है।
Payment Stream 1 — Monthly Maintenance
Paid every month by each resident
Rate: ₹5/sq.ft. × 1,900 sq.ft.
Supposed to cover: Society operations & all services
Payment Stream 2 — Electricity Bill (Paid on Top)
ऊपर से अलग electricity bill — हर महीने
All of the above paid SEPARATELY every month — in addition to ₹9,500 maintenance
The Big Question: Are any electricity-related costs already covered in the ₹9,500 maintenance? Society has NOT provided a cost allocation statement. Without it, we cannot rule out double charging.
Society ने cost allocation statement नहीं दी — इसलिए हम नहीं जान सकते कि double charging है या नहीं।
What Might We Be Paying Twice For?
| Cost Item | Covered in ₹9,500 Maintenance? | Also Charged in Electricity Bill? |
|---|---|---|
| Electrical staff / technician salary | ? — Not disclosed | ? — Not disclosed |
| Transformer maintenance | ? — Not disclosed | ? — Not disclosed |
| Meter installation & upkeep | ? — Not disclosed | ? — Not disclosed |
| DG generator maintenance cost | ? — Not disclosed | ✅ YES — ₹531/month confirmed in bill |
| DG diesel / fuel cost | ? — Not disclosed | ✅ YES — ₹30/unit confirmed in bill |
| Electrical infrastructure (wiring, panels) | ? — Not disclosed | ? — Not disclosed |
| Common area electricity cost | ? — Not disclosed | ? — Not disclosed |
| Billing software / platform fee | ? — Not disclosed | ✅ YES — ₹59/month confirmed in bill |
✅ = Confirmed charge appearing in electricity bill | ? = Society has provided no disclosure
DG maintenance (₹531) and Software fee (₹59) are confirmed in the electricity bill. If these same costs are already included in the ₹9,500 maintenance, residents are being charged twice.
The society MUST provide a full cost allocation statement — showing exactly what is covered in maintenance and what is separately billed in electricity.
DG maintenance और software का charge दोनों electricity bill में है। अगर यह maintenance में भी है — तो double charging है। Society को full breakup देना होगा।
Demand 1: Itemised Maintenance Breakup
Request a detailed monthly statement showing exactly how ₹9,500 is spent across all 10 services
Demand 2: Cross-Check With Electricity Bill
Society must show which electricity costs are in maintenance vs which are legitimately billed separately
Demand 3: Escalate if Unanswered
If management does not respond, escalate to RWA / Consumer Forum / RERA
NO RESIDENT SHOULD PAY TWICE FOR THE SAME SERVICE
TRANSPARENCY IS A RESIDENT'S RIGHT — Not a favour.
एक ही service के लिए दो बार payment नहीं होनी चाहिए। Transparency हमारा अधिकार है।
| What We're Comparing | Capital Gateway | Raheja Atlantis | Sobha City | ATS Kukoon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grid Rate (per unit) | ₹8.00 | ₹6.60 | ₹7.02 | — |
| DG Rate (per unit) | ₹30.00 | ₹29.36 | ₹24.00 | ₹26.66 |
| Fixed Grid Charge/month | ₹1,280 (always) | ₹0 | ₹0 | — |
| Fixed DG Charge/month | ₹531 (always) | ₹0 | ₹0 | ₹0 |
| Software Fee/month | ₹59 | ₹0 | ₹0 | — |
| Total Fixed Burden/month | ₹1,789 | ₹0 visible | ₹542 (CAM) | — |
| Total Fixed Burden/year | ₹21,468 | Not itemised | ₹6,505 | — |
| Maintenance (per sq.ft.) | ₹5.00 | — | CAM ₹542/mo | ₹3.50 |
| Total Bill (200G+20DG units) | ₹4,178 ← Highest | ₹2,247 ← Lowest | ₹2,513 | — |
| Annual Saving vs Capital Gateway | Benchmark (₹0) | ≥ ₹21,468/yr | ₹14,963/yr | — |
All data sourced from actual electricity bills, DHBVN office visits, and published tariff cards. May 2026.
Resident Reactions
Real feedback from Capital Gateway Society WhatsApp group after sharing the report at cgresidents.space
This is a fine piece of work. I applaud your highly evolved sense related to community living and the role of individuals in a community. The commitment you have demonstrated is rare. Thank you so much. Also, the RWA has already been formed and acknowledged by legal authorities — you may be able to share this work with them.
Good information, well presented. It should raise questions in our collective minds.
Brilliant work Aniket... Huge applause to you for the analysis and insights on the higher billing / comparisons & the way forward. Now this needs to be taken up for POA... Plan of Action!
I suggest all to go through the link shared above on billing report of CG...
This is a remarkable eyeopener... you did this for each one of us... grateful 🙏
Perfect display of the electricity cost concern.
Hopefully we may get to a resolution. 🙏
Special thanks to Mr. Sanjay Mishra who appointed me as a leader for this initiative and gave me the confidence to take up this cause on behalf of all residents. His trust in me was the foundation of this entire effort.
Deep gratitude to Mr. Sanjay Sarkar who encouraged me within the WhatsApp group to come forward and present this billing analysis for resolution. His push to make this a Plan of Action (POA) gave this work real momentum.
मेरे दिल की बात — My Personal Feelings
From Mr. Aniket Bhardwaj, Resident · Capital Gateway Society
जब मैंने पहली बार अपना electricity bill देखा और उसे neighbouring societies के bills से compare किया — मुझे बहुत तकलीफ हुई। हम एक ही शहर में, एक ही type की society में रहते हैं, same बिजली use करते हैं — फिर भी हम हर महीने ₹1,931 ज़्यादा pay कर रहे हैं।
When I first compared our electricity bill with neighbouring societies, I felt deeply troubled. Same city, same type of society, same electricity usage — yet we pay ₹1,931 more every single month. That is ₹23,172 per year — money that should stay in our families' pockets.
यह report मैंने किसी को नीचा दिखाने के लिए नहीं बनाई। मैंने यह इसलिए बनाई क्योंकि मुझे लगा कि हर resident को सच पता होना चाहिए। जब हम facts देखते हैं, तो हम सही सवाल पूछ सकते हैं — और सही सवाल ही बदलाव लाते हैं।
I did not make this report to embarrass anyone. I made it because every resident deserves to know the truth. Knowledge gives us the power to ask the right questions — and the right questions bring change.
Concern — चिंता
Every month ₹1,789 leaves each flat as fixed charges — before a single unit of electricity is consumed. This is not fair to hardworking families.
हर महीने ₹1,789 बिना बिजली use किये जाते हैं।
Discovery — खोज
When I showed the Atharva Raheja bill to the DHBVN officer, even he was surprised. Individual connections ARE possible via the builder portal.
Individual connections possible हैं — builder apply करे।
Hope — उम्मीद
I believe our management wants what is best for residents. This report is an invitation for dialogue — not confrontation. Together we can fix this.
मिलकर हम इसे सुधार सकते हैं।
Call to Action — आगे बढ़ें
Share this report with every neighbour. Ask management the five questions listed here. Demand a cost allocation statement. Transparency is our right.
यह report हर पड़ोसी को share करें।
अंत में — Our Demands & Way Forward
Demand 1
Society must provide a detailed monthly expense statement showing how ₹9,500 maintenance is spent across all 10 services.
₹9,500 का पूरा हिसाब दें।
Demand 2
Builder must register on DHBVN Unified Portal and apply for individual electricity connections for each flat — as already done by Atharva Raheja.
हर flat को अलग DHBVN connection।
Demand 3
Management must clarify if DG maintenance ₹531 and software ₹59 charged in electricity bill are already covered in the ₹9,500 maintenance — to prevent double charging.
Double charging बंद करो।
Demand 4
Management must justify the ₹1,280 fixed grid charge — given that Raheja Atlantis and Sobha City (same area) have ₹0 fixed grid charge for their residents.
Fixed charge justify करो या हटाओ।
Capital Gateway Hamara Ghar Hai
हम सब यहाँ खुशी से रहना चाहते हैं। इस report का मकसद लड़ाई नहीं, बल्कि fair treatment और transparency की माँग है। जब सब मिलकर सवाल पूछें — तो जवाब ज़रूर मिलता है।
We all want to live here happily. This report is not a fight — it is a demand for fair treatment and transparency. When residents stand together and ask the right questions, answers always come.
⚖️ Disclaimer
- This report has been prepared by Mr. Aniket Bhardwaj, a resident of Capital Gateway Society, in his personal capacity for informational and transparency purposes only.
- All figures, data, and bill screenshots used in this report are sourced from actual electricity bills, DHBVN office visits, and publicly available information. Every effort has been made to ensure accuracy.
- This report does not constitute legal advice, a formal complaint, or any official demand. It is intended purely to inform fellow residents and encourage transparent dialogue with society management.
- No personal attack or malicious intent is directed toward any individual, builder, management company, or DHBVN official. All comparisons are made in good faith using factual data.
- Readers are advised to verify all figures independently and consult appropriate legal or financial professionals before taking any formal action.
- The author accepts no liability for any decisions made by residents or management based on this report.
यह report सिर्फ जानकारी के लिए है। इसे किसी के खिलाफ नहीं, बल्कि transparency के पक्ष में बनाया गया है।